The rock tune was a bit too repetitious for me, and the cowbell (?) sounded too much like a metronome, but that's a personal thing
I agree. Think I got a bit carried away with the cowbell too...
This may depend on what speakers we listen on. Some have hotter transient response than others which makes things sound different. Have you listened to your songs on different audio/stereo systems?
At the time, I was using a Sony 'Megabass' system. The low-end was exaggerated a lot. Found it really hard to mix the kick and bass - it was either too low, or too high, when played on other systems.
I upgraded my hi-fi to a Denon AV amp, and it was much more accurate, even with the same speakers. I didn't re-mix the song though.
At the moment I'm using my mum's floor-standing speakers. I'm still unsure of how 'bassie' my mixes should be. I try and gauge by listening to CDs. The highs and mids are quite flat, but the bass is still exaggerated (Depending where you are in the room)... I try to get a balanced sound to my mixes (Bass/Treble/Mid), but it's hard to judge.
At college, I mixed a CD for one of the 'GAP students'. Guitar/vocal/bit of keys or percussion. It sounded fine in the studio (Teacher approved), but when I played it on my hi-fi, there was a low frequency hum on every single song. I was gutted because through the studio monitors, it sounded fine and you couldn't hear the hum.
So I think I need to think carefully about what monitors I buy for my new house/studio. Think I'm sticking with a A/V amp, as it has digital inputs, and then have a 2.1 speaker system. I just need to calibrate it properly, and listen to CDs on the system so I have an 'idea' of what my mixes 'should' sound like.
Gaz